Murder Most Foul

A woman in a red cloak. A drawn picture.

Here it is. The final film where Margaret Rutherford stars as Miss Marple. By the time I watched Murder Most Foul, I have to admit, I had gone a little batty with the theme song of these four movies. The same happens with Agatha Christie’s Poirot. Still, I am sad to be done with Margaret Rutherford as Miss Marple.

Miss Marple disrupts a jury

Margaret McGinty is dead. She was found hanging, and the police are certain they know exactly who killed her.

The police found a man at the scene, Harold Taylor. He was caught with his hands on the rope. So, he has to be guilty, right?

Not everyone thinks Taylor is a guilty man. What seems to be an open and shut case ends with a hung jury (that is not meant to be a play on words, I promise). While eleven vote guilty, there is one who will not be swayed to do so. That person is Miss Marple (Margaret Rutherford).

No one is happy about the hung jury which leads to a mistrial. This displeasure does not bother Miss Marple one bit. She knows declaring Taylor guilty is wrong. With the trial over, Miss Marple sets out to prove herself right.

Miss Marple starts her own investigation

The first thing Miss Marple does is visit Mrs. McGinty’s sister, Gladys Thomas (Megs Jenkins). Miss Marple pretends to be collecting for a jumble sale, which gives her the chance to snoop around while her friend Mr. Stringer (Stringer Davis) distracts Gladys. This charade is successful, but it is also noticed by the police.

Figuring out what Miss Marple is up to, Inspector Craddock (Charles Tingwell) tries to stop Miss Marple from continuing her investigation. By now he should really know better. If there is something Miss Marple wants to do, nothing is going to stop her.

Miss Marple becomes an actor

The clues Miss Marple found at Mrs. McGinty’s house lead her to a theater troupe. She tries out for the troupe, but the head of the troupe, H. Driffold Cosgood (Ron Moody), is unimpressed. Or at least he is until Miss Marple says she will work for free. Then there is no problem accepting Miss Marple into the troupe.

At the end of the audition, another actor, George Rowton (Maurice Good), stumbles onto the stage and dies. It is clear this is anything but a natural death. The police must be called in.

Another investigation begins

Craddock is not thrilled to discover Miss Marple is at the scene of the crime. While everyone else is able to give their statements at the theater, he forces Miss Marple to go to the station. I don’t know if he thought removing Miss Marple from the scene would get her to change her mind about investigating, or what, but it didn’t work. Miss Marple goes to the boarding house to stay with the rest of the troupe.

While Miss Marple pretends to be simply an aspiring actor, someone catches on that there is more to Miss Marple than what she presents. They decide to put a stop to her. A note is left on the floor to entice Miss Marple to a specific location at a specific time. The plan is for Miss Marple to be killed at this location. Someone else is killed instead.

Knowing full well someone is out to get her, Miss Marple decides to set a trap. She makes sure everyone sees a picture of a deceased female actor that she is sure is the key to everything. After she does this, she waits.

The gamble pays off. The murderer is caught, but only after Miss Marple is able to reveal what a champion shot she is. By now, I’m not sure there is any competition Miss Marple has not been champion in.

An older woman kneels over a body. A man is collapsed on the stairs.
Murder Most Foul
Charles Tingwell, Margaret Rutherford

The men of Miss Marple’s world

Mr. Stringer is so cute in this movie. He’s cute in every movie, but he was extra cute in this one. There is just something about this little old man working out to be sure he is strong and fit enough to come to Miss Marple’s aid if she needs it. Mr. Stringer is so sweet and will do absolutely anything for Miss Marple. The two actors portraying these characters were married in real life. Knowing that might be what makes the relationship between Miss Marple and Mr. Stringer even more adorable.

Then there is poor Inspector Craddock. At the end of the movie, he announces he is being promoted. I don’t know if this promotion includes a relocation, but Craddock is probably hoping it does. Anything that gives him less exposure to Miss Marple would probably be preferable. She is always telling him off about something, and he has a tendency to get injured on the cases she is involved in. However, Craddock’s rate for closing cases would be much lower without Miss Marple.

Never underestimate a woman

One of the things Miss Marple told Craddock off about was the intelligence of women. Craddock tried to imply Miss Marple had no idea what she was talking about with the murders because she was a woman. That was a big mistake. Miss Marple made it very clear that a woman can easily be the smartest person in the room. She then informed Craddock it would be best he not forget that fact. If he is smart, he won’t. Nor should anyone else.

Murder, She Said

Murder at the Gallop

Murder Ahoy

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Doctor Blake Mysteries

The Brokenwood Mysteries

George Gently